my signatures

these are my signatures, im new on photoshop and i want to see how im doing my sigs

well, your renders are waay to small. You want to make the render big and only put the focal point of the render on your sig. Also, for both your sigs, you've squished your text and render on the right side. You need to add much more depth to your sigs and also need to blend your render in much better. And a border might not hurt either. I'll give it a 5/10.

ManyBlackPpl i have never heard you say anything nice about somebodies sig without saying something bad aswell..

The only way to improve is by giving the negative comments, and the bg is ok, just render to small and text to big.

which is the real pixel for a signature?

Pyro wrote:which is the real pixel for a signature?

Try doing them around 350-380 width and 150-180 height.

EpiC//Swift wrote:ManyBlackPpl i have never heard you say anything nice about somebodies sig without saying something bad aswell..

replica/insaiine wrote:The only way to improve is by giving the negative comments

Exactly, the only way for someone to improve is if I also give them negative feedback. If I only give people positive feedback and don't tell them if there is a part of the signature that doesn't look good, then they will simply think they are doing a good job and will continue making pieces that aren't as good as they could be. Would you rather getting positive comments, continue making pieces that look like crap and have people talk behind your back about how crappy you are? Or would you rather someone be straight up with you so that you don't continue making crappy pieces and have people talk about how great you are?